Stranded/Trophy Fish

Item Requirement Chance Changed
Blobfish Blobfish No requirement. 15% ✕
Flyfish Flyfish The bobber must be at least 8 blocks below the player. 8% ✕
Golden Fish (Bronze) Golden Fish Fishing for 15+ minutes. See Trophy Fishes § Golden Fish. ✕
Gusher Gusher The biome must be changed with a Nether Biome Stick. 20% ✔
Karate Fish Karate Fish The player must punch the air and/or blocks at least 20 times after casting. 1% ✔
Lavahorse Lavahorse No requirement. 4% ✕
Mana Ray Mana Ray The player must have at least 1200 Mana. 4% ✕
Moldfin Moldfin There must be at least 8 Mycelium blocks within 5 blocks of the bobber. 2% ✔
Skeleton Fish Skeleton Fish There must be a Skeleton within 8 blocks of the bobber. 2% ✔
Slugfish Slugfish At least 20 seconds must pass between casting the rod and reeling it in. 10% ✕
Soul Fish Soul Fish There must be at least 8 Soul Sand blocks within 5 blocks of the bobber. 2% ✔
Steaming-Hot Flounder Steaming-Hot Flounder It must be raining, which can be controlled with a Weather Stick. 20% ✔
Sulphur Skitter Sulphur Skitter There must be at least 8 Sulphur in the player's inventory. 30% ✔
Vanille Vanille The player must use a clean Starter Lava Rod. Rod swapping makes this easier. 3% ✕
Volcanic Stonefish Volcanic Stonefish There must be a Hard Stone Minion within 8 blocks of the bobber. 3% ✔
Obfuscated 1 Obfuscated 1 The player must use Corrupted Bait. 25% ✕
Obfuscated 2 Obfuscated 2 The player must use Obfuscated 1 as bait. 20% ✕
Obfuscated 3 Obfuscated 3 The player must use Obfuscated 2 as bait. 10% ✕

Note: Obfuscated 1 Trophy Fish can also be obtained by killing Corrupted Sea Creatures, so using a Totem of Corruption on Sea Creatures to get a lot of Obfuscated 1 will help speed up the process when trying to get Obfuscated 2 and Obfuscated 3. Getting Obfuscated 1 from Corrupted Sea Creatures doesn't count for Odger's quest, so this method should only be used once all tiers of Obfuscated 1 have been obtained using Corrupted Bait.